Private Idaho: Mccall No. 1, 2024

Mccall No. 1, 2024

Two Idahos

There are two Idahos: Old and New.

The old one dug this ditch, strung this wire, and built this corral—a plain, working solution devised by our forebears to move water out of the Payette drainage, tended by families for generations.

The new Idaho lives in planned communities with pickleball courts, glittering ponds and fountains, and manicured everything.

For my entire life, McCall was a simple mountain town, with farms on its edges and cattle grazing in open, sprawling fields. Today, signs in those same pastures read: Homes from the low millions.

The two Idahos live shoulder to shoulder. We drive the same two-lane roads, attend the same churches, and pass each other in the grocery aisles. We wave. We say hello. We understand. Everyone wants the good life. We’ve had it so long.

But we ache.

We ache when an old homestead is scraped flat, its trees felled and pushed into a burn pile, a tall earthen berm thrown up along the highway until the view disappears.

We ache when our kids can’t afford a home in their own hometown.

We ache when we see a place like this, because we know what is coming: It’s going to disappear.


Discover more from

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Leave a Reply